Reviewing the Rolex Explorer II Polar Ref. 226570 is no small task. As one of the most revered tool watches from the world’s most iconic watchmaker, it stirs up a mix of nostalgia, admiration, and curiosity. The replica Rolex Explorer II has earned its place in the hearts of collectors, but its appeal varies based on one detail – its dial color. Today, we’ll take a closer look at the highly popular “Polar” version, with its striking white dial, often likened to the frozen expanse of the polar landscape.Â
This particular piece belongs to my brother, who recently purchased it from a local Rolex Authorized Dealer (AD). He’s generously allowed me to spend considerable time with it, so I can offer a thorough and detailed review.
A Brief History of the Explorer II
Since its debut in 1971, the Explorer II has been a symbol of rugged reliability. Designed with adventure in mind, it has served as a versatile companion for those navigating both land and sea. With features such as water resistance, a 24-hour GMT hand, and an overall durable build, it’s a watch that excels in functionality. The earlier models, such as the iconic reference 1655 (famously known as the “Steve McQueen”) and the 16550, featured more modest 40mm cases.
Design and Sizing: A Shift Towards Larger Proportions
The most notable change in the modern clone Rolex Explorer II Ref. 226570 is its size. At 42mm, it’s a departure from the 40mm case that many collectors consider the “perfect” size. The larger case has been a point of contention for some, especially for those with smaller wrists. For those considering the older models, the 40mm size was ideal for a wide range of wrist sizes, making it a more versatile option.
Personally, while I’ve always admired the Explorer II, the current 42mm version is a bit too large for my 6.5-inch wrist. I’m not a fan of the semi-hollow links found on the older 40mm models either, but I remain hopeful that Rolex will eventually release a new, more wrist-friendly version.
That said, the design of the Ref. 226570 is exceptional. Despite its larger case, the tapered lugs and slim profile ensure that the replica watch wears comfortably on the wrist. It’s impressive how Rolex has managed to maintain a refined aesthetic, even with the increased size, making it feel less bulky than its measurements suggest.
The Experience on the Wrist
Once on the wrist, the Rolex Explorer II Polar reveals itself as a true masterpiece of design. The stark white dial – reminiscent of icy tundras – offers excellent legibility at a glance. Its simplicity, however, doesn’t make it any less striking. Unlike other Rolex models, such as the Datejust or the Submariner, the Explorer II doesn’t scream “luxury” at first glance. This understated design allows it to fly under the radar, which is a quality I particularly appreciate.
In many ways, it shares a similar character with my Air-King 114200 – low-key, yet refined. When I wear it, I feel a sense of subtle confidence, knowing that it’s a watch that commands respect without needing to shout about it.Â
Dial and Bezel: A Timeless Design
The dial and bezel have always been the defining features of the Explorer II. The layout remains faithful to its roots, but with subtle enhancements that elevate the design. The hour markers and hands are slightly larger than previous models, outlined in black to improve contrast and readability. This “maxi-dial” approach, similar to the one found in the modern Submariner, adds a bold touch to the watch’s overall appearance.
Rolex’s commitment to symmetry is evident in the dial’s flawless execution. Unlike the Explorer I 39mm, which I felt had too much empty space, the Explorer II’s dial is perfectly balanced. Even the positioning of the Explorer text and crown logo feels harmonious, aligning with the watch’s sporty, utilitarian spirit.
The bright orange 24-hour GMT hand stands out against the white dial, offering an easy-to-read indicator for the second time zone. The date window, positioned at 3 o’clock, retains its iconic Cyclops lens, which blends seamlessly into the design.Â
As for the bezel, it remains true to its vintage design, featuring black-filled numerals and a bold, retro font. Initially, I wasn’t entirely sold on its blocky look, but over time, I’ve come to appreciate its unique charm. The bezel is a key element that connects the modern Explorer II to its storied past, and its design grows on you the more you learn about the watch’s history. It’s a feature that also benefits from a deeper appreciation of the legacy behind it – especially when you consider that the Explorer II has been worn by influential figures like actor Jason Statham.
The Rolex Explorer II Polar Ref. 226570 remains a perfect blend of tool watch functionality and luxury design. Its larger case size may not be for everyone, but the watch’s overall execution is near flawless. From its legible dial to its robust construction and iconic bezel, the Explorer II offers a timeless design that continues to evolve while staying true to its roots. For those who appreciate understated elegance, this watch is a true masterpiece that combines practicality with heritage in a way few other watches can match.